• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

  • Customer Training
  • Customer Support
  • Blog

Search

  • English

    Supply Chain Management Software (SCM Software) by Logility

    • Solutions
      • Advanced Analytics
      • Integrated Business Planning
      • Demand Optimization
      • Inventory Optimization
      • Sourcing Management
      • Supply Optimization
      • Quality & Compliance
      • Retail Optimization
      • Product Life Cycle Management
      • Supply Chain Data Management
      • Cloud Services
    • Industries
      • Consumer Goods
      • Furniture / Durable Goods
      • Electronics
      • Food & Beverage
      • Life Sciences
      • Process / Chemical
      • Retail
      • Service / Aftermarket Parts
      • Apparel / Softgoods
      • Wholesale Distribution
    • Resource Center
    • Company
      • Investor Relations
      • Contact Us
      • Careers
      • Leadership Team
      • Office Locations
      • Our Brands
      • Partners
    • News and Events
      • In The News
      • Events and Conferences
      • Press Releases
      • Press Inquiries
    • Contact Us
    • Solutions
      • Advanced Analytics
      • Integrated Business Planning
      • Demand Optimization
      • Inventory Optimization
      • Sourcing Management
      • Supply Optimization
      • Quality & Compliance
      • Retail Optimization
      • Product Life Cycle Management
      • Supply Chain Data Management
      • Cloud Services
    • Industries
      • Consumer Goods
      • Furniture / Durable Goods
      • Electronics
      • Food & Beverage
      • Life Sciences
      • Process / Chemical
      • Retail
      • Service / Aftermarket Parts
      • Apparel / Softgoods
      • Wholesale Distribution
    • Resource Center
    • Company
      • Investor Relations
      • Contact Us
      • Careers
      • Leadership Team
      • Office Locations
      • Our Brands
      • Partners
    • News and Events
      • In The News
      • Events and Conferences
      • Press Releases
      • Press Inquiries
    • Contact Us
    • Blog
    • Customer Support
    • Customer Training

    DDMRP – “Where’s the Beef”

    May 23, 2018 //  by Hank Canitz

    DDMRP – “Where’s the Beef”

    1. Home
    2. Blog
    3. DDMRP – “Where’s the Beef”

    DDMRPI will have to admit that I spent my fair share of time sitting in front of the TV set during my formative years. Unbelievably, we didn’t have computers, video games, or mobile devices back then so really the only form of in-home visual electronic entertainment was the TV, and by that I mean broadcast TV with maybe 10 channels of low-definition content if the rabbit ears were pointed in just the right directions. In my opinion, the limited choices helped make some of the shows very popular and memorable. There were also a few memorable commercials from those days. One of those is the 1984 Wendy’s commercial that featured a little old grandma shouting out in disbelief “Where’s the Beef” as she looked at a rather small hamburger patty. You can imagine this phrase became very popular at the time and applied to any number of situations. After researching Demand Driven Manufacturing Resource Planning (DDMRP) this old grandma popped into my head proclaiming, “Where’s the Beef?”

    Proponents of DDMRP proclaim this is a “new and revolutionary planning method.” In reality, pull-based replenishment has been around for many years. Basing near-term replenishment on demand signals like customer orders or POS data is common and has been supported by advanced planning and scheduling systems for some time. DDMRP proponents say that, “you don’t need forecasts for replenishment planning instead DDMRP bases replenishment on sales orders.” The reality is product lead-times for the majority of business environments are longer than customer replenishment lead-times so the math just doesn’t work out for most businesses. Proponents claim that, “DDMRP is the only approach that effectively synchronizes supply and demand across a complex and volatile supply network.” DDMRP can only determine where products should be stocked not how much to stock. Safety buffers are determined using simplistic backward looking logic that is equivalent to using a “naïve” approach. DDMRP tries to mask this fact by using multiple zones of inventory. In fact, DDMRP’s Average Daily Usage (ADU) is nothing more than a naïve forecast.

    So “Where’s the Beef?” The value of DDMRP has been reported with a significant amount of exaggeration, contradictions, and outrageous claims with little in the way of third party validation. Most of the boasts of DDMRP value are in comparison to the value of MRP. That is setting the bar very, very low. It is like boasting to a college music performance major that you play better than a 5th grader. DDMRP can reduce finished goods lead-times and inventory if your product lead-times can be reduced to meet customer replenishment lead-times. However, Advanced Planning and Scheduling (APS) systems have been delivering similar if not greater value than DDMRP for years. It is no wonder that most DDMRP success stories document the value obtained from going from simple MRP capabilities enabled through spreadsheets or ERP systems to DDMRP. Companies that have successfully implemented advanced planning and optimization capabilities would find limited or no value from DDMRP type capabilities.

    The real value for DDMRP could be appropriate for companies that run a make-to-order environment or can source everything locally and make their products in less than or equal to customer demand fulfillment lead-time. This describes a very small subset of company procurement and manufacturing environments. Maybe that is the reason Gartner believes the way to optimize a complex supply chain is through algorithmic planning. My advice: don’t pull out your MRP and APS solutions just yet. The question you need to ask, “Is it possible to reduce your longest production lead-times enough to meet current and projected customer order lead-times? If not, then the value you would receive from DDMRP may be very limited.”

    To learn more about building the foundation for Algorithmic Planning read, “Planning Optimized – Building a Sustainable Competitive Advantage“.

    Hank Canitz
    Hank Canitz

    Product Marketing Director Hank brings more than 25 years of experience building high performance supply chains. This experience includes evaluating, selecting, implementing, using and marketing supply chain technology. Hank’s graduate degree in SCM from Michigan State, numerous SCM certifications, diverse experience as a supply chain practitioner and experience in senior marketing roles with leading supply chain solution providers helps him to bring a unique perspective on supply chain best practices and supporting technology to the Voyager Blog.

    Recent Posts

    • 12 Steps to a Resilient Enterprise: Part 2 of 4
    • Import Bans from China Grow in US and UK
    • How Do You Turn Supply Chain Data Into Actionable Information?
    • Lot Traceability in the Fashion Industry
    • How Can Manufacturers Manage Disruption and Improve Productivity?

    Related White Papers

    • Five Ways to Build Advanced Supply Chain Planning and Optimization Capabilities in Process Chemical Industries
    • Supply Chain Planning Transformation – A Practitioner’s Roadmap
    • A Digital Transformation Guide for Supply Chain Disruptions

    Success with Logility

    • Citizen Improves Supply Chain Planning in No Time
    • Brightstar Revolutionizes End-to-End Supply Chain Performance
    • Clarios Powers a Digital Supply Chain Transformation
    Supply Chain Brief

    Category: Supply PlanningAsset Category: Demand Planning/Forecasting, Inventory Optimization/MEIO, S&OP/IBP

    Previous Post: «retail-supply-chain-bags Collections and Markdowns and BOGOs — oh my!
    Next Post: Question and Answer — Accelerate Supply Chain Performance Using Advanced Analytics SC-Analytics-Replay»

    Footer

    Solutions

    • Advanced Analytics
    • Integrated Business Planning
    • Demand Optimization
    • Inventory Optimization
    • Sourcing Management
    • Supply Optimization
    • Quality & Compliance
    • Retail Optimization
    • Product Life Cycle Management
    • Supply Chain Data Management
    • Cloud Services

    Industries

    • Consumer Goods
    • Furniture / Durable Goods
    • Electronics
    • Food & Beverage
    • Life Sciences
    • Process / Chemical
    • Retail
    • Service / Aftermarket Parts
    • Apparel / Softgoods
    • Wholesale Distribution

    Other

    • White Papers
    • Press Releases
    • Company
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    • Investor Relations
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Cookie Policy
    • Forward Looking Statement

    Our Brands

    • Logility Solutions
    • Halo Business Intelligence
    • Demand Solutions
    • NGC Software

    Social Media

    © 2021 American Software, Inc. All rights reserved.